The current discussion about the historical Jesus: problems and criteria
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.21906/rbl.15Keywords:
Historical Jesus, Leben-Jesu-Forschung, Third Quest, Jesus Seminar, ipsissima verba Jesu, ipsissima facta Jesu, ipsissima intentio Jesu, internal criteriaAbstract
The article presents the passage from the traditional defense of the historical value of the gospels (which followed the model of a judicial process in which the trustworthiness of witnesses and the eye-witness character of their testimony had to be proved) to the contemporary discussion, which for approximately the last fifty years has been developing and refining the criteria of historical reliability, in order to proceed to scrutinize each individual gospel text on these bases. His contribution lays out both the strong points and the weak points of the four criteria which end up being the most spendable and produce the most accurate results: the criteria of double dissimilarity, of multiple testimony, of coherence and of historical plausibility or sufficient explanation.
References
Aletti J.-N., “A Positive Criterion of Authenticity?”, Biblical Research 7 (1962), 33–44.
Aletti J.-N., “Exégete et théologien face aux recherches historiques sur Jésus”, Recherches de Science Religieuse 87 (1999) 3, 430–434.
Barbaglio G., Gesù ebreo di Galilea. Indagine storica, Bologna 2002.
Brandon S. G. F., Gesù e gli zeloti, Milano 1983.
Bultmann R., The History of the Synoptic Tradition, Oxford-Basil 1963.
Cadbury H. J., The Peril of Modernizing Jesus, New York 1937.
Chilton B. D., «Amen», in The Anchor Bible dictionary, I, 184–186.
Chilton B. D., The Prayers of Jesus, London 1967.
Crossan J. D., Four Other Gospels, Minneapolis 1985
Crossan J. D., The Cross That Spoke. The Origins of the Passion Narrative, San Francisco 1988.
Crossan J. D., The Historical Jesus. The Life of a Mediterranean Jewish Peasant, Edinburgh 1991, XXXII–XXXIII
Downing F. G., Christ and the Cynics. Jesus and Other Radical Preachers in First Century Tradition, Sheffield 1988.
Dunn J. D. G., Jesus Remembered, Grand Rapids, MI-Cambridge, U.K. 2003, 139–172 (Christianity in the Making, 1).
Fédou M., “«Le Jésus historique» des Pères de l’Église au temps des Réformes”, Recherches de Science Religieuse 87 (1999) 3, 333–352.
Fusco V., “Introduzione generale ai Sinottici” in M. Làconi (a cura di), Vangeli sinottici e Atti degli Apostoli, Torino 1999 (Logos, 5).
Fusco V., “La quête du Jésus historique. Bilan et perspectives”, in D. Marguerat, J.-M. Poffet, E. Norelli (éds.), Jésus de Nazareth. Nouvelles approches d’un énigme, Genève 1998, 25–57 (Le Monde de la Bible, 38).
Fusco V., “La ricerca del Gesù storico. Bilancio e prospettive”, in R. Fabris (a cura di), La parola di Dio cresceva (At 12, 24). Scritti in onore di Carlo Maria Martini nel suo 70° compleanno, Bologna 1998, 487–519.
Fusco V., Le prime Comunità Cristiane. Tradizioni e tendenze nel cristianesimo delle origini, Bologna 1997.
Holmén T., “Doubts about double dissimilarity. Restructuring the main criterion of Jesus-of-history research”, in B. Chilton, C. A. Evans (eds.), Authenticating the Words of Jesus, Leiden 1999, I, 47–80 (New Testament Tools and Studies, 28.1).
Jeremias J., Teologia del Nuovo Testamento, Brescia 1972.
Klausner J. G., Jesus of Nazareth: his life, times, and teaching [translated from the original Hebrew by Herbert Danby], London 1925.
Labriolle P. de, La Réaction païenne. Étude sur la polémique antichrétienne du Ier au Vie siècle, Paris 1942.
Lambiasi F., L’autenticità storica dei Vangeli. Studio di criteriologia, Bologna 21986 (Studi biblici, 4).
Léon-Dufour X., I Vangeli e la storia di Gesù, Milano 1968.
Léon-Dufour X., Les Évangiles et l’histoire de Jésus, Paris 1963
Mack B., A Myth of Innocence. Mark and Christian Origins, Philadelphia 1988.
Marguerat D., “La «troisième quête» du Jésus de l’histoire”, Recherches de Science Religieuse 87 (1999) 3, 397–421.
Marguerat D., L’homme qui venait de Nazareth. Ce qu’on peut aujourd’hui savoir de Jésus, Aubonne 31995, 114–115.
Martini C. M., “Adumbratur quomodo complenda videatur argumentatio pro historicitate evangeliorum synopticorum”, Verbum Domini 41 (1963), 3–10.
Martini C. M., “La primitiva predicazione apostolica e le sue caratteristiche”, Civiltà Cattolica 113 (1962) III, 246–255.
McArthur H. K., “A Survey of Recent Gospel Research”, Interpretation 18 (1964), 49–50.
Meier J. P., “The Historical Jesus and the Historical Samaritans”, Biblica 81 (2000), 218–222.
Parente F. (a cura di), I frammenti dell’Anonimo di Wolfenbüttel pubblicati da G. E. Lessing, Napoli 1977.
Penna R., I ritratti originali di Gesù il Cristo. Inizi e sviluppi della cristologia neotestamentaria, Cinisello Balsamo 32001.
Perrot Ch., “L’énigme néotestamentaire. Des figures de Jésus à sa particularité historique”, Lumière et Vie 210 (1992) 26.
Pesce M., «Discepolato gesuano e discepolato rabbinico», in Aufstieg und Niedergang der römischen Welt, II, 25/1, Berlin-New York 1982, 351–389.
Puig i Tàrrech A., “La recherche du Jésus historique”, Biblica 81 (2000), 179–201.
Quarles Ch. L., “The Gospel of Peter: Does It Contain a Precanonical Resurrection Narrative?”, in R. B. Stewart (ed.), The Resurrection of Jesus. John Dominic Crossan and N.T. Wright in Dialogue, Minneapolis, MN 2006, 106–120.
Sanders E. P., Gesù e il giudaismo, Genova 1992, 32–35.
Schlosser J., Gesù di Nazaret, Roma 2002.
Schlosser J., Le Dieu de Jésus. Étude exégétique, Paris 1987, 197–209.
Schürmann H., “«… und Lehrer». Die geistliche Eigenart des Lehrdienstes und sein Verhältnis zu anderen geistlichen Diensten in neutestamentlichen Zeitalter”, in W. Ernst (Hrsg.), Dienst der Vermittlung, Leipzig 1977, 107–147 (Erfurter theologische Studien, 37).
Schweitzer A., Geschichte der Leben-Jesu-Forschung, Tübingen 1913.
Schweitzer A., Storia della ricerca della vita di Gesù, Bologna 1986.
Schweitzer A., Von Reimarus zu Wrede, Tübingen 1906.
Theissen G., Winter D., Die Kriterienfrage in der Jesusforschung. Vom Differenzkriterium zum Plausibilitätskriteruim, Göttingen 1997.
Thüsing W., Die neutestamentlichen Theologien und Jesus Christus. Kriterien, Düsseldorf 1981.
Vermes G., Jesus the Jew. A Historian reading the Gospels, London 1973.
Wright N. T., “Quest for the historical Jesus”, The Anchor Bible dictionary, III, 796–802.
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License
that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal. - Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
